辩论资料.docx
- 文档编号:16404529
- 上传时间:2023-07-13
- 格式:DOCX
- 页数:12
- 大小:22.32KB
辩论资料.docx
《辩论资料.docx》由会员分享,可在线阅读,更多相关《辩论资料.docx(12页珍藏版)》请在冰点文库上搜索。
辩论资料
Affirmative-1:
Negative-1:
Affirmative-2:
Negative-2:
Affirmative-3:
Negative-3:
Affirmative-1:
Goodafternoon,Chair,adjudicators,thenegativeside,ladiesandgentlemen!
Fortoday’sdebating,asaffirmativeside,westronglyholdtheviewpointthathonestyisthebestpolicy.Astheaffirmative1,mystatementisdividedintothreeparts:
Inthefirstpart,I’dliketofivethedefinitionoftoday’smotion.
Threesecondpartistheoverallpointsofouraffirmativeside;
Andthethirdpartismyindividualstatement.
Firstofall,thedefinitionoftoday’smotionis“thequalityofbeinghonestandtruthfulnessisthemostdesirableprincipleforpeopletoliveby.”
Nextisthebrieflineofaffirmativeside.Here,theBESTmeansthemostdesirable.Mostdesirablepolicyonlymeansthatthepolicyisthemostimportantpolicyyoupursue.Youcanpursueotherpoliciesyoulike,buthonestyisthemostimportantamongothers.Honestyisthepremiseofotherpolicies.Withouthonestyiswithoutthebasicfeelingoftrustbetweeneachother.Otherpoliciesarebuiltupuponhonesty.
Followingaremyindividualpoints.Firstofall,homeandabroad,oldandnew,honestisalwaystreasuredasthebestpolicy.Forinstance,Lenin’shonestystoryistoldbyparentsandteacherseverywhere.Whenwearelittle,theveryfirstpersonalitywelearnmaybejusthonesty.Whyhonestyistaughttouswhenwewerestillkids?
Theansweris:
honestyisthebestpolicy.Whatismore,accordingtotheresearchdonebyStanfordUniversity,91%ofthetopcompaniesintheworldrequirethepersonalityofhonesty.Amongthem37%listhonestyasthetoponepersonalityfortheirstaff.Whywhenwehavegrownup,honestyisstillsoimportantforourlifeandcareer?
Thatmaybealsobecausethathonestyisthebestpolicy.
Whatarethebenefitsofhonesty?
Ifyouarehonesttoothers,theywillbehonesttoyouinreturn.Whenyouaresad,theywillcomfortyou.Whenyouareintrouble,theywillhelpyou.Toenumeratetheevilsofdishonestyiscountlesshere,butinaword,adishonestwillbelookeddownuponbyothersandregardasapublicenemy.HonestyisregardasthetraditionalvirtueofourChinesenation.Throughtheages,peoplestresssincerity,praisehighlysincerity.Ithasalreadyincorporatedthebloodofournationalculture.
Honestyisthebasicprincipleofpeople,withoutit,nothingcanbedone.Doyouliketodobusinesswithamanwhoistotallydishonest?
Hecangiveyoualotofpromisesbutmaynotmakeittruebecauseheisnothonest.
Herewesaythe“thequalityofbeinghonestandtruthfulnessisthemostdesirableprincipleforpeopletoliveby.”Pleasepayattentiontothewords“themostdesirable”wedonotsaythemostsuitable.Itmeansthatthehonestyisthebestpolicyorbeliefwepursue,wemaynotbeabletorealizeitineveryaspectbutweshouldtryourbesttorealizeit.
Later,myteammateswillgiveyoumoredetailsaboutthisissue.
Thankyou!
Negative-1:
Goodafternoon,dearChair,judgesandourfellowdebates.Asthenegativeside,wefirmlybelievethathonestyisnotthebestpolicy.
AccordingtoOxfordAdvancedlearner’sdictionary,honestyreferstothequalityofbeinghonest,whichhasthefurthermeaningofalwaystellingthetruth,neverstealingorcheating,andshowingandhonestmindorattitude.BasedonwhatisHONESTY,wecanhardlyagreewithwhatourfellowdebateshavesaidjustnow.Therefore,Iwilldividemyspeechintotwoparts.First,Iwillpointoutsomemistakesinourfellowdebater’sstatement;secondly,Iwillstateourpointofview.
Firstofall,Iwanttoaskmyfellowdebaters:
whatispolicyinyourmind?
Policyheremeanstheprinciplethatyoubelieveinthatinfluenceshowyoubehaveandthewayinwhichyouusuallybehave.WeadmitthathonestyistheBESTpolicysincetherearesomanyotherprincipleswecanbelieveinandatthesametime,wehavetobetraysomeofthemwhensomespecialoccasionhappensinourreallife.Yousaythathonestyisthebestpolicyanditisthebasicelementofallotherpolicies.Wecanhardlyagreewiththat.Ifhonestyisthebestpolicy,itmeansthatnootherthingisbetterthanHONESTY,andwhensomethinghasaconfrontationwithit,doesitmeanthatwealwayshavetofollowtheonlyprinciplewhichishonesty?
Theansweris:
no.
Secondly,Iwanttorestateourpointofview.Thissidefirmlybelievesthathonestyisnotthebestpolicy.Ononehand,therearesomanyprinciplesthatwebelieveinandthatinfluencesourbehaviors,suchasbravery,confidence,consistency,andsoon.Itishardforustodecidewhichoneismoreimportant,letalonetheBESTone.Theyareofequalimportanceanditisthesepoliciesandprinciplesthatformwhoweareandwhatwebelievein.Insomeoccasionswehavetochoosethemostimportantpolicyatthatmoment.Inthisperspective,myteammember2willexplainmore.
Lastbutnottheleast,allofushavetoadmitthathonestycanbequiteharmful,too.Sometimeswhenthetruthisbetterhiddentoprotecteveryone’sfeeling,awhitelieistoldtothepublicbecauseofsomeunspeakablereasons.Honestyisnotthebestpolicy,becauseitistheonethatwehavetofolloweverytimeortheonewehavetogivepriorityto.Instead,itcanbelessimportantthanthemaintenanceofthewholesituation,ortheprotectionforourbelovedonesformbeinghurtbytheso-calledTURTHwhichismeaninglessandcruel.Myteammember3willsaymoreaboutwhyhonestyisnotthebestpolicy.
Allinall,theresomanypoliciesthataresoimportantinourvaluesystemandwecanhardlydecidewhichoneistheBEST.Whatweshoulddoistofollowourheartandmakethebestdecisionofourselves.
Thankyou.
Affirmative-2:
DearJudges,ouropponentsandaudience,goodafternoon!
Wefirmlybelievethathonestyisthebestpolicy.JustnowNegativesaidthatundercertaincircumstanceswehavetobetrayhonestyandfollowsomefuleswhicharemoreimportant,sohonestyisnotthebestpolicy,butI’mafraidthatIcannotagreewithher.Weagreethattherearetimeswherewehavetogiveupalittlebitandfollowotherrules.Ibelievethatallofushavetoldsomewhitelies.Inthiscase,wecansaythatwearenotfollowingthebestpolicy,butitdoesn’tmeanhonestyisnolongerthebestpolicy.
Weallknowthatbestmeans“themostgood”,solet’stalkaboutgoodfirst.Ifwesaysomethingisgood,dowehavetoapplytoitanywhereanytime?
Idon’tthinkso.Nowpleaseletmegiveyouanexample.Let’ssupposethatonedayscientiststellyouthatriceisthebestamongallkindsoffood,andyoubelievethisistrue.Doesitmeanthatyouaregoingtoliveonricefortherestofyourlife,withouttakinganyotherfood?
Thatwouldberidiculous.
Thesameistruehere:
whenwesaythathonestyisthebestpolicy,wearenotsayingthatweshouldcastotherprinciplesasideandregardhonestyastheonlyrightthingintheworld.It’struethatthereareotherimportantrules.Forexample,kindnessisaverypreciousvirtue.Whenwearetellingwhitelies,thereisahiddenbeliefinourheartthatkindnessismorenecessarythanhonestyinthesituation.Butamorenecessarypolicydoesn’tequalabetterpolicy.AsIhavementionedbefore,ifricebecomesthebestfoodintheworld,wewouldprobablyeatricemorefrequently,butwestillhavetoeatvegetablesormeatwhenourbodyneedstheirnutrition.Forthesamereason,whenwearefacedwithsomesituationandkindnessisinneed,wehavenochoicebuttobeniceratherthantotallyhonest.
LadiesandGentlemen,doyoustillrememberthevariousstoriesyouheardwhenyouwerelittlechildren?
Manyofthemwereactuallyabouthonesty.FormerAmericanPresidentWashingtononcecutdownhisfather’scherrytreebymistake,andmusteredthecouragetotellthetruth.Leninoncebrokehisaunt’svase,andhetoldthetruth,too.Whyparentsalwaystelltheirkidsthesestorieswhentheyaresolittle?
Becausetheyknowhowimportanthonestyis.Theyknowthattheyhavetoteachtheirkidsthemosthonestythebestpolicyforaman,itisalsothebestpolicyforourcountry,anditisthemostimportantpolicywehavetotakeifwewantreachourgoal—toconstructaharmonioussociety.AccordingtoallIhavementionedabove,wefirmlybelievethathonestyisthebestpolicy.
Negative-2:
Goodafternoon,mydearchair,audienceandfellowdebaters.
Justasyourfirstdebatersaid,oursidefirmlyholdtheviewthathonestyisnotthebestpolicy.AtfirstI’dliketorebutsomeofyourpoints.Yourhavelistoutalotofbenefitsthathonestyhasbroughttous.Iwillnotdenybenefits.Butwhatwereallywanttoemphasizeisthatalthoughhonestyisaveryimportantcharacterforaperson,butitisnotthebestone.Thatmeansinouropinion,manyotherpoliciesareasimportantashonestysuchaskindness,persistence,bravenessandselflessness.Severaltimesinthestatementofouropponents,youhavemisledourunderstandingofthistopic.Yousethonestyanddishonestyisthebestpolicy,wemeanthatweagreewithdishonesty.Infactthepremiseofourviewisthatweadmithonestyisagoodquality,andlifeisindeedeasierifwearehonest.ButifIgivetwochoicestoyou,oneishonestyandtheotheriskindness,andwhenyouchooseoneofthem,youmustgiveuptheorder,andthenwhichonedoyouprefer?
Fromtheansweryoucaneasilyseethatmanygoodqualitiesareequal,theyarethesameimportantaseachother.Undermanycircumstancesitisreallyverydifficultforustotellwhichoneisthebest.
Second,Iwillillustratethatwhyweholdtheviewthathonestyisnotthebestpolicy.Ononehand,youcan’tsaythathonestyisthebestpolicy
- 配套讲稿:
如PPT文件的首页显示word图标,表示该PPT已包含配套word讲稿。双击word图标可打开word文档。
- 特殊限制:
部分文档作品中含有的国旗、国徽等图片,仅作为作品整体效果示例展示,禁止商用。设计者仅对作品中独创性部分享有著作权。
- 关 键 词:
- 辩论 资料